YEREVAN, Armenia (AP) — The head of the influential Armenian Apostolic Church appeared in court Friday for a trial on criminal charges as part of its latest confrontation with the government of Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan.
Catholicos Karekin II and six other senior clergymen are accused of defying a court order to reinstate a defrocked bishop. The case is widely seen as a part of long-simmering tensions between Pashinyan, who was reelected earlier this year, and the church, which has called for his ouster.
If convicted, Karekin and the other clerics could face up to two years in prison.
Relations between the powerful church and Pashinyan’s government have deteriorated rapidly since 2024, when tens of thousands of demonstrators, led by a high-ranking cleric, called for his ouster. They were angered by Armenia’s agreement to hand over control of several border villages to Azerbaijan and normalize relations with its neighbor after being locked for decades in territorial disputes.
Many clergy bitterly opposed the handover of the villages and criticized Pashinyan, who came to power in the South Caucasus nation amid a wave of hopeful, pro-democracy protests that swept Armenia in 2018. Some senior clerics have since faced a crackdown by the government.
The judge in the trial recuses himself
The first court hearing took place Friday in the central city of Vagharshapat, also known as Etchmiadzin, which is Armenia’s spiritual capital and the headquarters of the church.
Shortly after the hearing, Karekin’s lawyer Ara Zograbyan told reporters the judge in the case has recused himself.
“I welcome this move by the judge, because in effect he refused to become a part of this shameful proceeding,”Zograbyan said, adding that the case will be assigned to a new judge.
Hundreds of Karekin’s supporters gathered outside the courthouse in Vagharshapat, which is located about 18 kilometers (11 miles) west of Armenia’s capital, Yerevan. Members of opposition parties, clergy leaders and representatives of nongovernmental organizations also came for the hearing.
Samvel Karapetyan, head of the pro-Russian opposition party Strong Armenia, called the case against Karekin a “national disgrace.”
“It seemed that maybe the authorities would come to their senses and stop their attacks on the church, but they’re keeping at it,” local media quoted him as saying.
The case of a defrocked bishop led to the charges
The charges arose after the church in January defrocked Bishop Gevorg Saroyan, who had previously called for Karekin’s ouster. The church accused Saroyan of abuse of power. Saroyan contested the move in court, which sided with him and ordered his reinstatement.
The church refused, and Armenia’s Prosecutor General’s office launched the case against Karekin and the other clerics in February, accusing them of defying a court order and barring them from leaving the country.
Two other top clergymen were arrested last year. Archbishop Mikael Ajapahyan was convicted of calling for the overthrow of the government, and Archbishop Bagrat Galstanyan, who led the anti-government protests in 2024, is currently under house arrest awaiting trial on charges of attempting a coup, fomenting mass unrest and preparing a terrorist attack.
Earlier this year, an appellate court overturned Ajapahyan’s conviction and ordered a new trial.
Sign up for Morning Wire: Our flagship newsletter breaks down the biggest headlines of the day.
Clerics denounce the case as an assault on church autonomy
During an evening service at the Etchmiadzin Cathedral, Karekin denounced the case against him.
“These days the authorities take steps to undermine the church’s authority, restrict its autonomy and subjugate it to their will,” he said, adding that the institution’s autonomy is at the core of Armenia’s prosperity.
Archbishop Natan Hovhannisyan, head of the Department of External Relations and Protocol of the church and one of the defendants, said the church is not an entity that can be “nationalized, expropriated and have a manager appointed.”
—-
Karmanau reported from Tallinn, Estonia.
